Sophie Parker
From Misinformation to Reality: The True Story Behind the Senate Hearing Arrests
What the Claim Says
The claim is that U.S. Armed Forces male and female pilots refused to fly arms-laden aircraft to Israel, were summoned to the Pentagon, then forcibly arrested and handcuffed.
What Reliable Sources Say
The claim has been investigated by multiple fact-checking organizations, including Fact Crescendo and The Quint. Key findings:
-
The individuals shown in a viral video (Anthony Aguilar and Josephine Guilbeau) are U.S. Army veterans, not active-duty pilots. TheQuint+1
-
They were arrested for disrupting a U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing, protesting U.S. policy towards Israel, not for refusing military orders or refusing to fly weapon shipments. TheQuint+1
-
There is no credible evidence of active service members being arrested for refusing to transport weapons to Israel. Fact Crescendo Sri Lanka+1
Verdict
The claim is false / misleading. The video does not show what is claimed in the viral post. There is no verified incident of U.S. military pilots being arrested at the Pentagon for refusing missions to fly weapons to Israel.
| Claim (Viral Version) | Verified Reality / What Sources Show | Notes & Caveats |
|---|---|---|
| U.S. male & female pilots refused to carry weapon-laden aircraft to Israel. | The individuals involved were military veterans, not active U.S. Air Force (or other branch) pilots commanded to fly weapons. Yahoo+1 | The viral claim inflates their status and role (making them “pilots who refused orders”) to sound more dramatic. |
| They were summoned to the Pentagon and forcibly arrested for that refusal (and handcuffed). | They were removed and handcuffed after disrupting a U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing—not at the Pentagon for refusing service orders. Democracy Now!+2we are Mitú. 100% American & Latino+2 | The setting, cause, and actors differ significantly from the viral narrative. |
| This happened because they would not transport weapons to Israel. | Their arrest was in the context of a protest; they accused the U.S. of complicity in Israel’s actions in Gaza during the Senate hearing. The Dissenter+2Democracy Now!+2 | The protest was about U.S. foreign policy, not about refusing a direct military order. |
| The clip is being removed from the Internet, so share it before it disappears. | Fact-checkers and reputable outlets have already examined and published rebuttals of the viral framing. Yahoo+1 | The “before it’s deleted” narrative often accompanies misinformation. |
| The purpose is to expose that “America is primarily responsible for the destruction of Palestine.” | While the protesters make strong accusations, the verified fact is only that veterans disrupted a hearing and were arrested, not that the U.S. has been legally proven as “primary destroyer” in this case. Democracy Now!+2we are Mitú. 100% American & Latino+2 | The viral message adds an interpretation/generalization beyond what is documented. |
🧠 Summary & Guidance
-
-
The core event is real: two U.S. military veterans (Anthony Aguilar and Josephine Guilbeau) were removed and handcuffed during a Senate hearing after interrupting and protesting. Democracy Now!+2The Dissenter+2
-
However, the viral version misrepresents nearly every other detail: calling them “pilots,” claiming they were arrested at the Pentagon for refusing weapon transport, and framing it solely in terms of that refusal.
-
-
The protest was directed at U.S. policy toward Israel and Gaza; the manner in which their actions are being described (in viral posts) has added dramatic twists that are unsupported by credible evidence.
Aparna Ganguly
Sikander@87